Summary
| Website: | vic.libertarians.org.au |
| Social Media: | Facebook — Instagram — X / Twitter |
| Previous Names: | Liberal Democrats |
| Slogans: | F*** Around and Find Out |
| Themes: | Bold assertions of received Libertarian or right wing ‘wisdom’ with little or no proof |
| Upper House Electorates: | North-Eastern Metropolitan Region, South-Eastern Metropolitan Region, Western Victoria Region |
| Lower House Electorates: | Benambra, Berwick, Brighton, Carrum, Clarinda, Cranbourne, Croydon, Dandenong, Eltham, Malvern, Melbourne, Mordialloc, Mulgrave, Narre Warren North, Narre Warren South, Northcote, Ovens Valley, Pakenham, Richmond, Ripon, Rowville, Warrandyte, Yan Yean |
| Preferences: | The Libertarians are directing preferences oddly this time around. There’s no How To Vote card at all for Western Victoria, the HTV for South-Eastern Metro says put them at number 1 and do what you want with the other boxes. The card for North Eastern Metro does have preferences: the DLP at 2, Family First at 3, One Nation at 4 and the Liberals at 5. |
| Previous Reviews: | 2022 (VIC) — 2022 — 2019 — 2018 (VIC) — 2014 (VIC) — 2013 — 2010 |
Policies & Commentary
Few things speak more to the Libertarian mindset than the absolute conviction that anything a government does must be directed against them personally. On this particular occasion, they’re up in arms about the government’s (modest) reforms to the state electoral system, which they regard as having put them in, in their words “an unprecedented fight for survival.1italics mine; bold in original” These changes mean, allegedly, that “Under the new system, the quota for getting re-elected is now a massive 16.7% of the primary vote” – a quota which, they contend, will make it difficult for David Limbrick to be re-elected.
Another thing that speaks to their mindset is their unwillingness to let the truth get in the way of feeling like hard done by. In this case, they are mistaken about the nature of the changes to our system. While there were changes made to how elections are run in Victoria, no changes were made to the quota of votes required – see for yourself. At the very least, this is shoddy research on the party’s part. It won’t be the last such, alas.
Law and Order
The Libertarian Party, who like to style themselves as champions of freedom, is very much of the opinion that accused criminals have too much of it. They want to see bail restricted to first offences only for violent crimes – which isn’t necessarily bad policy, just one that sits ill at ease with their avowed principles – and a two strikes rule for the same crimes. They also want to fast-track serious cases, with “fixed timelines” being a part of that. Because obviously, witness testimony always takes the exact same amount of time, every time, as do jury deliberations. It’s actually grimly amusing that this measure, if enacted, would almost certainly lead to more frequent mis-trials, thus having the exact opposite effect it is intended to. They also intend to recruit 1000 more police, although how they intend to make that an attractive proposition to potential employees is not addressed. But apparently it will be paid for with money to be saved by cancelling the SRL (of which, more anon). The Libertarians, much like the SFF, want to legalise pepper spray2Pepper spray also gets its own separate heading as a policy, but there’s no detail there not also in this section, so I won’t be dealing with it separately. and what they call Castle Law (i.e. relaxed burden of proof for self defence when defending one’s own home)3which also has its own section, and which I will also not be dealing with separately for the same reasons. While they’re in a legalising mood, they also want to legalise vapes, reduce the excise on tobacco and legalise cannabis, all with an eye to reducing crime and the cost of policing – although in the latter case, they’ve also done the costings to show how it could be a new profit centre for the government. It’s notable that, despite the service being freely available to them, this is the only part of their entire platform they’ve had costed. Remember that, because a great number of their policies harp on savings, and this is the only one they’ve actually troubled themselves to verify that for.
Oh, and they also intend to hold a Royal Commission into the CFMEU, presumably in addition to the one that will already have been running for more than two months by election day4This one goes beyond merely shoddy research, since all you would need to do to know about the Royal Commission is watch the damn news once in a while. This is either laziness in not updating their site, or it’s deliberately mis-leading..
Housing Crisis
The Libertarian prescription for solving the housing crisis is to abolish Stamp Duty (cutting government revenue and little else, unless those totally non-greedy real estate agents somehow fail to pass along the savings); the abolish the urban growth boundary; to abolish zoning restrictions and heritage overlays; to abolish restrictions on new construction (because the most important freedom is the freedom to recklessly endanger the lives of others). All of this is completely stupid.I am unconvinced that these solutions will not simply create other problems.
Cancel the SRL
The Libertarian Party wants to cancel the SRL, aka, the Suburban Rail Loop. They start off by arguing this on financial grounds, but rapidly move on to opposing it on the grounds that it’s “something most of us will likely never live to see”, because who cares about future generations? They then segue to outright conspiracy theories, asking “Is it possible that the government have mortgaged Victoria to China for the sake of loans to stave of Victoria’s debt disaster?” (Short answer: no, it is not, that’s not how these loans work.) They then move on once more to the threat of the dreaded CFMEU, and demand answers… which, as already mentioned, we are in the process of getting at the Royal Commission. They also seem to think that cancelling the SRL will somehow get back all the money that’s already been spent on it.
Immediate Tax Relief
Hopefully, the old saying that you are what you eat is untrue, as the Libertarians warn that “You pay for food. You don’t realise that stamp duty tax, payroll tax and more state taxes are in your food bill.” (I’m not sure how stamp duty gets in there, unless you’re accustomed to eating properties.) But fear not! The Libertarians have “a bold plan to reverse this mess”, and here it is:
- Dump the Emergency Services and Volunteer Fund levy.
Fund these services directly by the government without a special fund.- Axe Stamp Duty
Buying a home shouldn’t come with a punishing tax bill. We’ll phase stamp duty down to 0%—permanently. Buying a home will be cheaper.- Cut Payroll Tax
Punishing businesses for creating jobs? Insanity. We’ll slash payroll tax by over 65% to boost wages and help create jobs.
First off, emergency services are already funded by the government, that’s how that works. I can’t see how reducing the amount of tax paid will make it easier for the government to afford this. Stamp Duty I’ve already discussed above. Payroll Tax is another case of them assuming that of course the savings will be passed along. All of these proposals are highly specific – they claim to provide general tax relief, but only actually do so for the owners of properties or businesses. Anyone else benefits only indirectly, if at all.
Cancelling the SRL comes up again as a savings item here, and there’s also “A 4% cut to government bureaucrat spending each year” (with carve-outs for teachers, nurses, police, paramedics, etc), which is the kind of one-size-fits-all thinking that parties on the right seem to love uncritically.5“One size fits all” rarely works at a scale lower than that of universes.
Government Spending
This is, obviously, the bête noire of Libertarians everywhere, and our homegrown version is very much on trend. Here’s what they want:
THE REVOLUTION: CONSTITUTIONAL SPENDING LIMITS
- Force balanced budgets – no more borrowing sprees.
- Cap spending at 15% – government can’t grow bigger than the economy.
- Complete transparency – every dollar tracked publicly.
- Stop secret slush funds.
- Cancel the Suburban Rail Loop debt bomb.
- Strong spending watchdogs.
First of all, “balanced budgets” are not actually as important as responsible and responsive government. Governments all over the world went into deficit to deal with covid, and that was the sensible thing to do. The insistence on balanced budgets – not just on this party’s part – is a waste of time. What matters more is what the money is spent on, and whether it’s value for money6If their opposition to the SRL was couched in those terms (like the Liberal Party’s is, for example), I’d treat it more seriously..
I am not sure what effect a cap on government spending like they describe would have, but it does seem like a thing that would reduce the flexibility of governments in responding to emergencies. Transparency does seem a worthwhile idea, but I’d want to see some limits on it – tracking hospital spending, for example, shouldn’t violate patient privacy. And I think we can all agree that secret slush funds are a thing to be stopped. I am curious about their ‘strong spending watchdogs’, and in particular, how they’re to be paid for. (Come to think of it, establishing and maintaining the transparency they want would also have a price tag.)
WHAT YOU GET:
- No more debt passed to you, and future generations
- Government that serves YOU, not itself
- Modern, efficient services at lower cost
- Direct control over YOUR tax dollars
I can see where the first two points come in, based on the foregoing – not convinced of the mechanisms or their efficacy, mind you, but I’m willing to accept that that’s the intent. The latter two points, on the other hand, seem to be – and this is a charitable way to describe it – lacking some intermediate steps. How do we get there from here?
Affordable Energy and Dump Net Zero
Let’s start with a nice strong scare quote, shall we?
VICTORIA HAS MASSIVE ENERGY RESOURCES
SO WHY DO YOU PAY THE WORLD’S HIGHEST POWER BILLS?
Oh, that’s easy: we don’t. Our cost per kWh is lower than that of most European nations, and we rank equal 24th globally on that measure. So yes, it could be lower, but we’re comparable or better than most other developed nations. (Stats from the World Population Review.)
The Libertarian Party would like to see “a true free market” in electricity and believe that Victoria’s power grid is currently “over-regulated”. They want to end mandates and subsidies in this field, and they want to open it up to all forms of power generation. Which, yes, means they want nuclear power, because apparently “Modern nuclear is safe, efficient, and clean”. As per usual with anyone advocating nuclear power, there is no mention of how waste will be dealt with, or indeed, of its existence. They also want to see more interconnections between state power grids, which does seem like a good idea to me.
On the Dump Net Zero front – they want to make Net Zero voluntary rather than mandatory. Mostly because it’s getting in the way of all the coal, oil and gas they want to burn.
Look, there’s quite a bit more here, but I think you get the idea of where they’re coming from. There are sections about property rights (briefly: you should be able to do what you want on your property), about introducing a US style school voucher system (which has produced few or no benefits to actual education, but has done a great job of funneling public money to private providers) which would also be used to support home-schooling, And an approach to the great outdoors that is more or less identical to that of the Shooters, Fishers and Farmers Party. There are two remaining policy areas I’m going to treat in more detail.
Free Speech
Libertarians have long been free speech absolutists and the laundry list of things they want to repeal is certainly indicative of that. They want to repeal the Social Cohesion act, and other anti-vilification laws7The temptation to engage in vilification of this party is very strong right now, but I will resist. For a little while longer.. They also want to modify the conversion practices ban, while ensuring that “coercion, force and harm to children stay illegal” – because apparently there’s no such thing as verbal coercion or harm.
On the other hand, they also want to see “Refused Classification” bans removed for “anything legal for adults in the US, UK, Canada and NZ” – so it’s bad if our government censors things, but it’s okay if other governments do? They also “Oppose “misinformation” and “online safety” censorship” and “Refuse the “Digital Duty of Care””, because freedom, I guess.
Sex Based Rights
The Libertarian party supports “the right of people with diverse sexualities and gender expressions to live their lives in the way that brings them the most satisfaction” which sure sounds supportive of the LGBTQ+ community. Sadly, that’s a mere motherhood statement, as they also support the right to vilify LGBTQ+ people; the right to refuse them admission or membership to community groups – and very specifically sporting groups too; the right of parents to be consulted regarding their children’s transitions and wants to see “a broad and systematic review of youth gender medical treatment, similar to the UK Cass review.”
Or, you know, they want to be able to abuse queer folk for being queer, to discriminate against trans people, and to treat children as the property of their parents. For a self-proclaimed party of freedom, this goes against pretty much everything they claim to believe in. Libertarians used to stand for something. It was a stupid, selfish and self-destructive something, but they at least had ideals. Now they’re little more than another far right party in libertarian drag. They will going second last on my ballot8because yes, PHON are still worse. The Libertarians have been fucking around for some time now, and I hope they find out just how unpopular they are come election day.


Leave a Reply